As I mentioned in my ELF custom palette post, I thought the 2 eyeshadows I bought were dupes for MAC Woodwinked and Black Tied. I compared them today and I was way off with Woodwinked but almost spot on for Black Tied.
Woodwinked and Moondust are nothing like each other! Moondust is a proper brown whereas Woodwinked has far more golden/amber tones.
However, Black tied is almost identical to Dusk, in fact, I think Dusk is better. It’s what I want Black Tied to be. Pigmented, easy to blend, and the glitter is finer so it’s less chunky than Black Tied.
They look very similar in pan too
So a very cheap MAC dupe at £1.50.
You can buy it here